What’s so special about Cooperstown, New York? 10 fun reasons to visit

Yes, I am a lover of baseball. I won’t deny learning about the art of bat-making at the family-run Cooperstown Bat Company’s factory in Cooperstown, New York, fascinated me. But I wasn’t prepared for how much I would love Cooperstown itself — nor did I leave myself enough time to see and do it all.

What’s so special about Cooperstown?

Located in Upstate New York between Albany and Syracuse, Cooperstown is home to the National Baseball Hall of Fame and Museum. This place had me feeling like an overstimulated child at Disney World; it’s a huge draw for the town and a big reason people travel from all over the country to get there.

However, whether you’re a baseball fan or not, Cooperstown has plenty to offer. Here are 10 (non-baseball) places to go and things to do in Cooperstown.

Glimmerglass boat tour

The first thing we did upon arriving in Cooperstown was hop aboard the Glimmerglass Queen, one of the 10 Best Boat Tours of 2022, for a narrated boat tour of Otsego Lake. It was the perfect opportunity to get some fresh air after our drive, take in the natural surroundings, start unwinding, and gain a bit of historical context for the area.

Be aware that the Glimmerglass Queen only operates Wednesday through Sunday and is cash only, so be sure to come prepared.

Brewery Ommegang

Located upon a 136-acre picturesque farmstead, Brewery Ommegang lays claim as America’s first farmhouse brewery in over 100 years. Whether you’re a fan of Belgian beers, are looking to be introduced through a guided tasting, or want some great pub food, Brewery Ommegang is a sure bet. Be sure to check the events calendar, as there’s always something exciting going on, from salsa dancing and live bands to Sunday Brunch Bingo.

For more craft breweries, wineries, distilleries, and cideries, check out the Cooperstown Beverage Trail.

Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard

Fly Creek Cider Mill & Orchard is an excellent spot if you’re traveling with kids, but it is still very much worth a visit without them. For over 160 years, the folks at Fly Creek have been using a water-powered mill to press delicious ciders and have built up a farm store and snack bar (apple cider donuts, anyone?) around it.

Those traveling with kids will enjoy exploring the grounds, feeding the ducks, gem mining, and the Tractorland play area. Others may like to sample some of the hard ciders in the tasting room or explore the Mill Store Marketplace, which is stocked with unique gift ideas and features hundreds of Fly Creek Mill specialty items, like cheeses, jams, pies, sauces, fudge, and ciders.

Be sure to try the Molasses Crinkle cookies! They were my favorite.

Glimmerglass State Park

Glimmerglass State Park, just outside Cooperstown, is a great spot to soak in the tranquility of nature all year round. Whether you’re interested in fishing, camping, hiking, swimming, or biking, there are plenty of activities to keep you busy. The Beaver Pond Nature Trail is an easily accessible trail for those looking to explore the woods leisurely. At the same time, the Sleeping Lion Trail rewards those willing to put in a little extra effort with panoramic views of the lake.

Leatherstocking Golf Course at Otesaga Resort Hotel

Designed in 1909 by renowned architect Devereux Emmet, the Leatherstocking Golf Course at Otesaga Resort is considered by many to be one of the best courses in the Northeast. Set along the side of Otsego Lake, this par-72 course seamlessly blends natural beauty with challenging play and builds up plenty of anticipation with the iconic final holes. Hole 17 requires a demanding shot over up to 195 yards of water, while Hole 18 incorporates an island tee and fairway along the lake.

Mini-golf more your thing? Check out Barnyard Swing.

The Farmers’ Museum

Perfect for history buffs and families searching for an immersive experience, The Farmers’ Museum in Cooperstown brings the history of 19th-century rural New York to life. Fun, fascinating, and informative, The Farmers’ Museum invites visitors to witness daily life unfolding on a working farm and stroll through the village to observe artisans at work.

Don’t miss the Empire State Carousel while you’re out this way!

Fenimore Art Museum

Visitors will find the Fenimore Art Museum just across the street from The Farmers’ Museum. Housed within a 1933 mansion formerly owned by novelist James Fenimore Cooper (author of “The Last of the Mohicans”), the Fenimore Art Museum boasts an impressive collection of American folk art, paintings, and decorative arts. Whether you’re interested in art, history, literature, or architecture, Fenimore is worth visiting while you’re in Cooperstown.

Hawkeye Spa at Otesaga Resort Hotel

Charmingly located along the banks of Otsego Lake, Otesaga Resort Hotel offers stunning lake views and a peaceful atmosphere that will leave guests feeling refreshed, but if you’re looking for even more relaxation, book a day in the Hawkeye Spa. Treatments inspired by natural elements and local traditions include massage, facial, and microdermabrasion. Whether you need some me-time or are planning a romantic getaway or girls’ trip, the folks at Hawkeye Spa will be able to provide precisely what you need.

Pedal rail with Rail Explorers USA

Low impact, safe, and fun for all ages, Cooperstown Rail Explorers USA offers the perfect active and yet leisurely activity — a ride aboard a pedal-powered railroad cart. Take in the scenic beauty of Cooperstown as you pass by the rolling hills of upstate New York’s many farms, through wooded areas, and over the Susquehanna River via train trestle.

Be sure to leave some time to explore the small museum, operated by the Leatherstocking Railway Historical Society, in the Rail Explorers’ depot for historical context about the rails you will ride.

Cooperstown Cheese Company

The Cooperstown Cheese Company is not to be missed. This lovely little shop has cases of their award-winning, artisanal cheeses on display, and guests are welcome to sample as they shop! Beyond the cheese, other locally sourced goods like jams, honey, dried meats, and other unique treats can be found at Cooperstown Cheese Company, but do not leave town without first getting your hands on a couple of slices of their cheesecake!

About Catherine Smith

Catherine Smith, Readers’ Choice Awards Production Manager and Social Media Director for USA TODAY 10Best, has a special interest in unique culinary experiences and off-the-beaten-path adventures.
Catherine is the founder of Her Bags Were Packed where she focuses on helping women release emotional baggage through solo travel and self-discovery.